
Fast-Moving Tech and Regulation Require an Adaptable Audit Committee2026 has been an active year for technology, financial regulation, and the public company audit profession. Consequently, rapid changes in these areas underscore the importance of audit committees staying informed to understand the impact on a company’s financial reporting environment. With so much movement happening at once, audit committees must remain attentive to evolving risks and developments as they carry out their fiduciary responsibilities to shareholders. We welcome input; please let us know what you think. Was this email forwarded to you? Create your CAQ Dashboard and sign up for our newsletters so that you never miss an update from the CAQ. In This Issue
PCAOB Inspections: Better results, but no time for complacencyThe PCAOB continues to focus on inspections with recent publications including its annual Staff Update on 2025 Inspections of Public Company Audits and new materials from the Inspections Modernization Council (IMC).Across 780 engagements inspected covering 143 firms, there has been a broad year-over-year improvement in audit quality: Part I.A Deficiency Rates
The staff observed several developments and potential drivers of improvement including more in-person work, more focused training, additional resources, improved supervision and review, sustained focus on quality control, accountability, and use of technology. While improvements continue under the current inspections program, the IMC continues its work. Building on August 2026 materials, the IMC published a potential severity scale for both engagement-level and firms’ system of quality control-level inspection findings that includes the following scale (from most to least severe):
Among other developments, the materials present alternative options for inspection reporting that include a long-form, short-form, and short-form abbreviated report structure. Chairman Jim Logothetis and the Board have made clear that inspections modernization continues to be at the forefront of the PCAOB’s priority list. See the CAQ’s Guide to PCAOB Inspections here, including a tool for audit committees in Appendix B. Fraud Oversight: Policies and Procedures Are Not EnoughThe audit committee has a crucial role in overseeing the financial reporting process, including efforts to deter and detect fraud. While management is responsible for maintaining and diligently applying robust written procedures, the audit committee has a critical role in overseeing how fraud risks are identified and mitigated. As we wind down 2026, check out the following resources to assist in fighting fraud at the forefront. Thought Leadership: BDO and the AICPA outline factors that could weaken audit committee oversight of fraud, especially in a fast-moving technological environment that has seen the growth of AI agents and other autonomous (distinct from automated) technological systems. To mitigate these factors, it discusses the importance of strong vertical communication channels that span all the way to the audit committee (a framework coined as the “Candor Chain”). One way to implement these channels is to provide critical functions, like internal audit, within the financial reporting environment access to the audit committee without senior management’s presence. Case Study: The Anti-Fraud Collaboration (a partnership that includes the CAQ) recently published an update to the Oteal Pharmaceuticals case study. The update captures the newest characteristics of the global, economic, and technological environments (including the use of AI in accounting processes). Without spoiling the plot, the case contains an important message for audit committees: be deliberate (and slow if needed) when implementing AI tools. Regulatory: The SEC recently posted a new episode of its podcast Material Matters, titled “Back to Basics in SEC Enforcement.” Director of the Division of Enforcement David Woodcock sits down with Chairman Paul Atkins to discuss, among many topics, how the SEC is responding to real investor harm and addressing fraud schemes that leverage emerging technology like digital assets and artificial intelligence. Questions for Audit Committees to Consider
AI Agents: Autonomous Tech Demands Active Board InvolvementAs boards oversee the governance and risk management of companies’ AI environments, their attention must also be directed to incident responses involving autonomous AI agents. According to recent research by Grant Thornton, 35% of business leaders cite “operational risk from autonomous or semi-autonomous actions” as their top concern about implementing agentic AI. However, the same study found that only 20% have developed an “incident response playbook” and have tested it. While agentic AI is impacting many areas within companies, audit committees should be aware of how such tools are used in the financial reporting process, and how an incident’s pervasive impact might affect ICFR. New technology amplifies the number of vulnerabilities to which an organization is exposed; like fraud risk, the risk of an agent attack is compounded by the pace of technological change. Having a plan is crucial to guard against the threat of an autonomous agent incident, and audit committees play an important role in highlighting the financial reporting perspective to the board. Questions for Audit Committees to Consider
CAQ’s Audit Committee Council Spotlight: Gary DiCamillo, Audit Committee Chair, Purple Innovation, Inc.We sat down with Gary DiCamillo, a member of the CAQ’s Audit Committee Council, to shed light on his career and journey to the audit committee. Read on to learn about Gary’s journey. How did you get started in accounting? What was your first and last job? I’m not a CPA, but I’ve been around accounting for a long time. I’m an engineer by training, and I took my first accounting class at Harvard Business School. It was called Control, and I actually liked it and did well. I started as a brand manager at Procter & Gamble, then spent four years at McKinsey, where I came to understand what really goes into financial statements: what they can show, what they can hide, and how to analyze them. That proved valuable in every job since. I spent the next 25 years running companies, including Polaroid, where I served as chairman and CEO. At 60, I stepped back to focus on board work, though I twice stepped in as CEO of private equity-owned companies, most recently Universal Trailer Corporation. What was the first corporate board that you joined? How did you get on that board? I had just moved to Baltimore, and the owner of Sheridan Press, a privately held printing company, read about me in the newspaper. Through that connection, I joined the boards of The Sheridan Group and EIL, a small public company, and served on both audit committees. That was almost 40 years ago, and I’ve been on audit committees ever since, chairing six of them. What do you enjoy most about serving on an audit committee? How is it different from other board committees? The audit committee is the linchpin of all board committees. We have ultimate oversight of the quality and accuracy of the financial statements, and we either stand behind them or challenge them. That’s vital for investors, employees, and other stakeholders. What I enjoy most is asking questions. I run the audit committee focused on the business and our shareholders, and I’ll often ask, “Why is that rule the way it is?” You’ve got to understand the business to truly audit correctly. What else do you do outside of board service? I play golf (I played on my college team), and I love to cook Italian food, though my son is a better cook. We also love doting on our seven grandchildren, and we have one more on the way. I’m treasurer of my church and chair the finance committees of Spoleto Festival USA and the Charleston Opera Theater. For someone who isn’t a CPA, I spend a lot of time in finance and audit. What trends or risks do you think audit committees will need to focus on in the next few years? AI is a trend we have to watch carefully. I think it will change auditing more than people realize. When you can digest data the way AI does, you have to step back and rethink sampling and how you look at companies. More broadly, the focus needs to stay on quality and rigor. Monitoring what goes into audits, and what goes wrong with them, is very important. In addition to Gary’s role on the board of Purple Innovation, Inc., where he serves as the audit committee chair, he is a trustee and chair of the finance committee of Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute and a member of the College of Charleston Board of Governors. He previously served as chairman and CEO of Polaroid Corporation and served on the board of directors of Whirlpool Corporation from 1997 to 2023, chairing the audit committee from 2015 to 2020. He joined the CAQ’s Audit Committee Council in December 2020. ICYMI: CAQ Public Policy Technical Alert (PPTA), October 2026Each month, the PPTA highlights and examines the regulatory, standard-setting, legislative, and broader financial reporting developments impacting the public company audit profession. The CAQ’s October 2026 Alert included these featured topics. CAQ Comment Letter: SEC Regulation Crypto Assets The CAQ recently submitted a comment letter to the SEC responding to its proposed Regulation Crypto Assets. The letter addresses reporting requirements for the SEC’s proposed “Tier 1” and “Tier 2” issuers, suggests collaboration between the financial regulators and the FASB to develop clear expectations around digital asset accounting and auditing, and recommends the SEC clarify its definition of a public business entity to match GAAP. Comments were due October 20, and the SEC’s next step is to finalize the proposed rule, after which it would become binding on applicable entities. PCAOB Meetings The PCAOB held meetings of two of its advisory groups, the Investor Advisory Group (IAG) and the Standards and Emerging Issues Advisory Group (SEIAG) during October; the IAG met on October 21st, and the SEIAG on the 30th. Chair Logothetis and board members attended both meetings and shared insights into the PCAOB’s areas of focus with input from the two advisory groups.
Upcoming EventsThroughout November and December, audit committees have an opportunity to listen to different firms and the wider audit industry’s perspectives on the current financial reporting ecosystem as we close out 2026. Below is a list of upcoming webinars available for committee members:
A Look Back at the White House Turkey Pardon TraditionEvery Thanksgiving, a White House tradition has persisted that the President should publicly spare the life of one live turkey in a show of goodwill towards our feathered friends; this act of avian justice occurs at the National Thanksgiving Turkey Presentation, though it has absorbed the nickname of an annual “turkey pardon.” According to the White House Historical Association, legend suggests that the act of “pardoning a turkey” originated with President Abraham Lincoln in 1863, when his son Tad requested that his father release the bird that was to be prepared for a family holiday dinner; notably, however, this commutation occurred at Christmas time. Though Lincoln’s story is unconfirmed, the presidential tradition formally began to take shape in the 1940s, when Harry Truman hosted televised presentations featuring live turkeys to promote nationwide food conservation. Partnering with the National Turkey Federation and National Egg and Poultry Board, the presentations included practical ways for Americans to reduce their consumption, with one guideline stating to “Use no poultry or eggs on Thursdays.” The tradition solidified in the 1980s during Ronald Reagan’s presidency, and the phrase “presidential pardon” directed at a turkey was first used by George H.W. Bush in 1989.
The turkey has a storied history not just around the American dinner table but also in American politics; on that note, instead of politics, may this anecdote provide a palatable conversation topic at your family Thanksgiving gathering this year. |
||||||||||||||||
|
Questions and comments about Audit Committee Insights can be addressed to Vanessa Teitelbaum, Senior Director, Professional Practice (vteitelbaum@thecaq.org). This newsletter is intended as general information and should not be relied upon as being definitive or all-inclusive. The CAQ encourages readers to refer to applicable rules, standards, guidance, and other resources in their entirety. All entities should carefully evaluate which requirements apply to their respective organizations. About the Center for Audit Quality The CAQ champions the public interest in the capital markets by:
As the voice of the public company audit profession, we work to instill trust in corporate reporting and the integrity of the auditing process, ultimately empowering investors, companies, and society as a whole. For more information, visit www.thecaq.org.
|
